Wednesday, February 29, 2012

Playing “Good Cop, Bad Cop” with Octopuses

Have you ever seen an octopus in an aquarium, or maybe even in the ocean, and thought, “I know you!”? No? Well, they might think that when they see you!

We’ve known for some time that many domestic animals, like dogs, can tell us people apart. It turns out that a lot of animal species can recognize individual people. But how do we humans know that? It’s not like you can walk right up to an animal and say “Hey! Remember me?” ...Well, I guess you could do that, but how would you interpret the answer?

Imagine everything that an animal would have to be capable of to be able to recognize different people: the animal would have to be able to discriminate, learn and remember. Those are pretty complex tasks. Despite our stereotypes of molluscs, octopuses (not “octopi”) are actually quite good at all of these things. They are visual animals that can differentiate between abstract shapes, remember visual patterns, and be conditioned (Conditioning is a process by which an animal learns to associate a behavior with some previously unrelated stimulus). Additionally, many people acknowledge octopuses as the most intelligent (and coolest) of all invertebrates. Furthermore, there have been several anecdotal reports of octopuses recognizing individual people. Some octopuses at aquariums consistently approach the keepers that feed them, even when the keeper is in a crowd of other people. One octopus being trained in a lever-pressing task regularly chose to squirt the researcher in the face rather than press the lever. Another octopus apparently only jetted water at a particular night guard. So octopuses seem like a pretty good species to test individual human recognition (and to test for a sense of humor, but that is for another day).

If you were an octopus, could you tell these two people apart?
Photo by Veronica von Allworden from a figure in the paper
in The Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science
Roland Anderson and Stephanie Zimsen at the Seattle Aquarium, Jennifer Mather at the University of Lethbridge, and Mathieu Monette at the University of Brussels, set out to do just that. They caught eight giant Pacific octopuses from the wild and took them to the Seattle Aquarium. For 5 days a week over two weeks, they repeated the following process: Two identically-dressed testers played the roles of “good cop” and “bad cop”. Twice a day for each animal, each of the two testers would separately open the tank so they could be seen by the octopus and record its behavior: movements, inking, blowing water, funnel direction, skin color and texture, respiration rate, and the presence or absence of an eyebar (color-changing skin around the eye that may darken due to disturbance). Then, one of them would feed the octopus, and the other would gently poke it with a bristly stick (which was not harmful, but probably pretty irritating). The “good cop” always fed the octopus and the “bad cop” always poked it, although the people that played “good cop” and “bad cop” were different for each animal. The order of the “good cop” and “bad cop” treatments was determined randomly each day. On the last day of the second week, each tester opened the tanks, looked in, and recorded the animals’ behavior.
A giant Pacific octopus displaying his eyebar (shown with the white arrow)
in the wild. Photo by Veronica von Allworden from a figure in the paper in
The Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science
In the first day or two of testing, octopuses generally moved away from both testers equally, did not have a difference in where their water jets faced or in displaying their eyebars. But in the second week, octopuses generally responded to testers that fed them by moving towards them, aiming their water jets away from them and not displaying eyebars; they generally responded to testers that poked them by displaying their eyebars, aiming their water jets at them, and moving away from them. And some of the octopuses (the larger ones) had faster breathing rates when they saw the testers that poked them than when they saw the testers that fed them.

So octopuses can recognize individual humans, and they treat people differently depending on how they have been treated by the humans. …Hmmm… If octopuses can do it, imagine what other species may be able to do it. Meditate on that the next time you interact with an animal.

Now add individual human recognition to other things we know octopuses can do, like learn and remember skills, play with toys, express personalities, and detect things by vision and smell. And they can do this:

and this:

and this:

I mean really, is there anything octopuses can’t do?

Do you want to get to know the octopuses from this study? Learn to recognize them at the Seattle Aquarium or the Seaside Aquarium, where they are now on exhibit.

Want to know more? Check these out:

1. Anderson RC, Mather JA, Monette MQ, & Zimsen SR (2010). Octopuses (Enteroctopus dofleini) recognize individual humans. Journal of applied animal welfare science : JAAWS, 13 (3), 261-72 PMID: 20563906

2. Mather, J.A., Anderson, R.C and Wood, J.B. (2010). Octopus: The Ocean’s Intelligent Invertebrate. Timber Press, Portland, OR.

3. Octopus Chronicles, a Scientific American blog dedicated to everything fascinating and amazing about octopuses

4. AnimalWise, a blog about animal cognition

3 comments:

  1. I volunteer at the Seattle Aquarium and I have definitely noticed that particular octopuses will either play with the pole during feedings while other individuals ignored me. The particular octopus that played with the pole did it consistently every saturday that I volunteered...I'd have to check with the rest of my interpretation group to see if they had the same experience

    The individual I mentioned might have had more of a tendency towards curiosity compared with other individuals, but he wasn't the only one to demonstrate it. I've noticed that the other octopuses tended to also play with the pole, whether I was feeding them or not. The same goes for the ones that would just take the food and leave the pole alone.
    At the aquarium we have two public feedings, same time each day, where different volunteers wearing the same blue shirt put ladders or sit on top of the tank to conduct feedings or enrichment. I think they recognize that at a certain time of day, someone in a blue shirt with a pole will feed them while more people watch. I've heard that individual octopuses at the aquarium have reacted differently to the main biologists who care for them, depending on how they were treated.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the insight Jennifer! There is also some really interesting research on "personalities" in cephalopods.

    ReplyDelete